Don’t Become a Scientist!

Don’t Become a Scientist!

老文了,看到那些幻想做科研,或者靠学位xxx的人,于心不忍。
写的是米国,但是中国的情况更糟:制造的数量更多(还拿来吹),但是产业更低级。
唯一的6 & m好处是,有些单位i P P G ~ , h A还要认学历做敲门砖。如果你不能靠关系混一个的话 就靠青春吧

Don’t BZ – f Tecome a Scientist!
J, \ 7 x 4onathan I. Katz
Professor of Physics
Washington University, St. Louis, Mo.
[my last name]@wuphys.wustl.edu
千万别成为科学家!
约拿单 I. 卡茨,物理学教授,华盛顿大学
Are y& A $ ~ ? n Y Lou thinking of becoming a scientist? Do you want to uncover the
mysteries of nature, performe k w experiments or ca] K | Rrry out calculations to learn
how the world works? Forget it!
Science is fun and excitQ c c eing. The thril* & O 4 f m ~ I Yl of discovery is unique. If you are
smart, ambitious and hard working youz q 7 ( ( u should major in science; + Y P 7 % ( as an
undergraduate. But that it $ 4 N u Hs as far as you should tm , ) _ W 2 Sake it. After gradA _ r \ m F Muation,
you will have tJ E `o d3 l ` q P T $eal with the real world. That means that you shoq 5 j E m culd not
even consider going to graduate school in science. Do something else instead
: medical school, law school, computers or engineering,u ) [ 5 } 7 or something else
which appeals to you.
你在打算成为科学家吗?你想揭开自然的奥秘、用做实验或计算的方式来研究整Q p Y &个世界
是怎么运作的?把这个想法忘了吧!
的确,科学很有趣,也很刺激。由发现而产生的强烈快感是独一无m O l P 5 E ;二的。如果你很聪明
、有野心,} ^ \ 6 h G i \ 4并且也很刻苦努力的话,你的确应该在读本科的时候选择科学。但这就够了
,到此为止。本科毕业之后,你将必须面对这个真实的世界。这意味着,你不应该哪怕
是考虑去读科学方面的研究生。做点其他的行当吧:医学、法律、计算机、工程,或者
其他随便什么你能想到的。
Why am I (a tenured professZ e ^ , W O Uor of physics) trying to discourage youV / u f W \ ~ from
follow& p K ling a ca1 ; sreer path which was suH ) $ j h u =ccessful forE G R @ & 2 ) ( p me? Because times have
changed (I received my Ph.D. in 1973, and tenure in 1976). Am| ^ = } p U {erican scs ( : C ]ience
no longer offers a reasonable career path.– D ) v 2 G If you go to graduate school in
s# R / 7 4 . ~ o ccience it is in the expectatiop & w q f } & F !n of spending your working life doing
scientific research, using& t A k 8 ? p Q m your ingenuity| 4 C N O and curiosity to solve important
and interesting problemq l Y Q ( 8 A | :s. You will almost certainly be disappointed,
probably when it is too late to choose another career.
American unive` k U 6 6 i )rsities trainj ( \ roughly twice as many Ph.D.s as therec i 3 ! G 5 w | are jobs
for them. When something, or someone, is a glut on the market, the price
drops. In t% A + C @ 4 M She case of PF Q C n rh.D. scientists, the reduction in price takes the
form of many years spent in “holding pattern” postdoctoral jobs. Permanent
jobs don’t pay much lesa s { Ns than they used to, but instead of obtaining a
real job two years after the Ph.D. (as was typical 25 yeZ T A P w X c )ars ago) most younW \ t [ b 1 ^ l tg
scientists spend five, ten, or more years as postdocs. They have no prospect
of permanent employment and often must obtain a new postdoctora. ^ b 4 d *l position
and move every two years. 4 O & ~ * 0 2 Q. For many more detaiW : : f L ! / * dls consult the Young Sciw w & S R y \entists
’ Network orG ! M k read the account in the May, 2001 issue of the Washington
MS ] | i b | ` fonthly.
为什么我,一个有终身职位的物理学教授,一个在科学事业F e B S # N O y上很成功的人,要来试图打
击你们将科学作为毕生事业的勇气和信心呢?因为世道变了。我1973年拿到我的博士学
位,1976年就拿到了终身教职。美国的科学界现在已经不能提供一条合理的事业生涯的X N u
途C # \ ~ / p径了。如果你去读科S $ # ?学的研究生,你大概D x d T J ( i一定会期望着用你毕生的工作精力去做科学
研究,J | w } 8 w用你的智慧和好奇心去解决那些重要而又有趣的问题。实话讲,你基本上一` 5 I定会
失望,而失望的时候,你大概已经错过了选择其u @ 3 M { –他任何职业的机会。
美国的大学制造了两倍于其工作职位数量的博士。当随便一个什么东西,或一种人,满
大街随便捡的时候,他就不值钱了。对于博士科学家来说,掉价的形式是他们不得不用
许多年做一期又一期的博士后,H O ?等待着一个工作机会的到来。永久职位不N u % # i /会比以往给的
薪水少多少,但25j K k f J Z K 0年前一个博士毕业后大约2年后就能找到一个真正的工作,而现在绝
大多数的年轻科4 s N E U学家– P . c q z都得当5年,10年,甚至更久的博( d L J } R !士后。他们没什么拿到永久/ e W ? { p h $职位
的盼头,常常必须每两年找一个新的博士后工作,然后搬家。欲知更多N # . w详情,请咨询“
青年科学家协会”A I ~ p Q – ? ,或读一读华盛顿大学月报 2001年5月的文章。
As examples, consider two of the leading candidates for q P C v f 7r a recent Assistant
Professorship in my deg E 0 u 3 e Tpartment. One was 37, ten years out of graduate school
(he didn’t get the job). Th) e l ^ X ~ 9e leading candidate, whom everyone thinks is
brill) ^ niant, was 35, sevB 0 9 T o 8 8 2 Ben years out of graduate school. Only then was he
offered hip L xs first permR _ ; j H 8 H Ranent job (that’s not tenure, just the possibility of
it six years later, and a step off the treadmill of looking for a nc i T 0 + p Iew job
every two years). The latest exaO @ / = * X Z &mple is a 39 year old candidate for another
Assistant Professorship; he has published 35 papt 0 ( Kers. In contrast, a doctor
typically enters private practicr y Y _e at 29, a lawyer at 25 and makes partner at
31, and a computer scientist with a P@ L h [ O i } uh.D. has a very good job at 27 (
computer science and engineering are the fu \ f c j K ]ew fields in which industrial
demand makes it sensible to get a Ph.D.). Anyone with the intelligence,
ambition and willingness to work h6 : 4 ? xard to s. ? Ducceed i6 M $ : H Xn science can also succeedw ! j | 2 ;
in any of these other p!
rofessions.
Typical postdoctoral salaries begin at ?e ? ~ l a i R a L,000 annually in the biological
sciences and about ?,000 in the physical sciences (graduate student stipends
are less than half these figures). Can you support a family on that income?
It suffices for a you6 6 f K 5 Yng couple in a small a] | K :partment, though I know of one
physicist whose wifB o : w r M y Ce left him because she was tired of repeatedly moving
with little prospectk & \ + V w of settling down. When you are in your thirties you
will need more: a house in a good school district and all the other
necessi1 | q B h H Fties of ordinary middle class life. Science is a profession, not a
religious vocation, and does not justify an oath of poverty or celibacy.
就拿我们系里最牛的两( P B h u o ? d :个准备竞争一个讲师职位的人来作例子。一个\ C v [家伙37岁,博士毕
业已经10年了,一直没找到工作。另一个最牛的家伙? ~ – J 5 W h _,35岁,人人都t ) v认为他很聪明,博
士毕业7年了才找到一个“永久工作”(其实不是永久教职,只是6 年后有希望获得永
久教职而已,o y ^ X * X不过这已经让他稍稍i I a远离那种每两年就要找新博士后工作搬家的驴拉磨死
循环了)。还有一个例子,一个39岁的家伙,想竞聘另一个讲{ m v K n ? ? d师职位。他发了35篇文章
。与之形成鲜明c r X 4 L ; \对比的是,一个典型的医生29岁就进入了实习阶段,一个典型的律师25
岁就开始实习,3– t & 2 C 6 = q ~1岁正式进事务所,一个计算机博士科学家在27岁时已经能得到很好的
工作了。计算机科Q # R学和工E 8 , ! U程科学是工业界需要人才的仅有的两个领域,因此这两个行当
还是值得去读个博士出来的。任何一个人,如果他有智慧和野心,能刻苦工作,如果他
能在科学上成功的话,他也能在其他任何行当上成功。
典型的博士后薪水是每年27000美元(b [ % _ h 8 O生物科学)或37 w Q z \ o t5000美元(物理科学)。博士生的
奖学金比这个一半还少s ) n s E v C G。用这么点收入你能支h [ ~ v = [ 3持一个家庭吗?嗯,够年轻的小两口住一
个很小的房子。不过我认识一个物理学家,他的妻子T t + [ o Y W ) ~把他踹了% 9 y m j ~ \,因为她是在厌倦了跟他
不停地搬家却一点定居的希望都看不到。当你三十多岁的时候你就会需要更多的东西:
一个大房子,附近有好的学校,以及其他中产阶级生活所必需的设施。科学是一个职9 a G业
,而不是一个宗教的呼召,也不是一个贫穷或独身的判决或者宣誓。
Of course, you don’t go into scien* 3 l h e 2 x 8ce to get rich. So you c+ . +hoose not to go
to medical or law school, even thoug9 K ! ih a doctor or lawyer typically earns two
to three timeso X z – Y _ r as much as a scientist (one lucky enough toS 0 – 3 ~ – have a good
senior-level job). I made7 o % @ x that choice too. I became a scientist in order to
have the freedom to work on problems which intere0 / V l G Qst me. But you probV U 7ably won
’t get t– d p u ghat freedom. As a postdoc you will wo9 O j 8 srk on someone else’s ideas,
and may be treated as a technician rather than as an indepe# q M # \ wndent
collaborator. Eventually, you will probably be squeezed out of science
entirely. YoR t 8 v 0 I A (u can get a fin7 y L ie job as a computer programmer, but why not d@ p X v ,o
this at 22, rather than putting up with a decade of misery in the scientific
job markW : B ? E l – Eet first? The longer you spend in science the harder yo4 j p Pu will find
it to leave, and the less attrk 2 R 8 Kactive you will be to p1 P L # Lrospective employers in
other fieldso , ) o ` + G.
Perhaps you are so talenteq Q ! M z rd that you can beat the postdoc trap; some
unive( ) , H R 8 q krsity (there are hardly any industrial jobs in the physical sciences)
will be so impressed with you that you will be hired into a tenure track
position two years out of graduate school. Maybe. But the general cheapening
of scientific labor means that even the most talented stay on the
postdoL A ^ Fctoral treadmill for a very long time; consider the job candidates
described above. And many who appear to be very talented, with grades and
recommendations to& [ – v f w match, later find that the competiti3 D T 8 J * hon of research is
more difficult, or at least different, and that they must struggle with the
rest.
显然,你走科学道C N % t s } & z 1路并不能使你发财――你没7 p X W .有选择去读医学或法律,而一个医生或律
师典型的收入是科学家的) 3 W2-3倍(这还得是那些运气忒好的正教授科学家们)。我m ! i v f也做
了这个选择。我成s F 7 y G为一个科学家是为了有自由来解决那些让我感兴趣的问题。但你可能
并不能得到这种自由W @ Z N。作为一j = 1 ) e ~ ;个博士后,你只能按照别人的想法来工作,可能被当成一
个技术员来使唤,而不是作为一个单独的科学家来合作。最终,你可能被彻底排挤出科
学界。你可以得到一份很好的工作,比如计算机程序员,但为什么不在你22岁的时候做
这份好工作,而要在科学界的人才市场上面悲悲惨惨地混上10年先?你再科学上面花c \ 2 B z $的
时间越多E $ a ~,你会发现你越难离开,而且你对Z E y / G u x \ /其他行当的雇主而言变得越来T @ I ! N # (越没有吸引力。
也许你脑瓜足够灵* O S v X Y w g ;光,以至于你能跳出博士后= G $ Z D : f C 1的陷阱。Z _ 8 f u [有些大学会被你打动而在你博士
毕业2年后给你一个可能的永久职位。这是可能的。但是科学劳动力市场的整体掉价意
味着最灵光的K B ; c $ W { `脑瓜也得被拴在博士后磨盘上当驴转上很长时间。想想上面举过的例子吧
。许多看上去非常有才而且有傲人的: D I成绩和推* x Y _ ^ v i荐信的人,后来发现研究上的竞争比其他
一切的奋斗都要困难。
Suppose you d@ J W # z Ho eventually obtain a permanent job, perhaps a tenured
professorship. The struggU $ C o c U U \ Qle for a job is now replaced by a stP A ] G N 7ruggle for
grant support, and again there is a glut of scientists. Now youm 1 L j s– \ ( Ppend your
time writing proposals rather than doing research. Worse, because your
prop( ? ` K [ S H Hosals are judged by your competitors you cannot follow your curiositya { R _ [ G l Z,
but must spend your effort and talents on anticipating and defleK j A K { i gcting
criticism rather than on solving the important scientific probs s 2lemsy l m $ Q _ j x 5. Th= 7 * X y Dey’% 3 A @ | 6re
not the same thing: you cannot put your past successes in a proposal,
because they are finished work, and your new ideas, however original and
clever, areV _ – A \ W J [ still unproven. It is proverbial that original ideas are the
kiss of death for a proposal; because the& % U %y have not0 l * yet bee` D x On proved to work
(after all, that is what you are proposing to do) they can be, and will be,
rated poorly. Having achieved the promised land, you find that it is not
what you wanted after all.
What can be done? T\ T \ P C B uhe firs% l % ! 2 \ $t thing for any young person (which means anyone
who doeO 8 : f E 2 0 R ys not have a permanent job in science) to do is to pursue another
career. This will spare you the miR ? j & = C Ysery of disappointed exp6 P X S ( * = 0ectations. Young
Americans have generally woken up to the bad prospects and absence of a
reasonable@ T a ] $ N S s : middle class career path in science and are desert, g Ping it. If you
haven’t yet, then join them. Leave graduate school to people from IndiaB # / l A O I ] – and
China, for whom the prospects at home are even worse. I have known more
people whose lives have been ruined\ M n 6 P ! k by getting a Ph.D. in physics than by
drugs.
假设你最终拿到了一个永b 3 K J ;久教职,一E 4 _ T i C ^ L B个终身教授职位。现在$ W s 4 B F你不必为每两年一次的工作
而s g I奋斗,取而代之的是为v E n W | f q . b研究经费而斗争。你会又一次地发现,这个世界上的科学家有
一大箩筐,而你自己又不值钱了。现在你焚膏继晷地写研究计划,而不是去做研究。更
糟糕的是,因为你的研究计K k [ \ p M p R划会被你的同行竞争者来审阅,你就不能按照你自己所好奇
的东西来写。你得把你的努力和聪明才智浪费在怎么咬文嚼字地让那帮混蛋不要挑刺上
,而不是去解决重要的科学问题。这是两个截然不同的事情^ D 7:你不能把你过去的成功写
进研究计划,因为那些是已经完成的工作;而那些原创性的天才想法还没有被证明。一
句谚语说,原创性的想法是研究计Z – W ? P ) \划中的死神之吻(乍看有益但实则会导致毁灭的行为
),因为这些想法根本就没有被证明可行(废话,被证明可行了你还写个屁的研究计划
),因此它们会被认为是垃圾。因此,当你费劲千辛万苦终于到达了那“应许之地”的7 i $
教授职位上,你会发现这根本就不是你原来想要的。H S ; \ p | ,
那么b E C : b x l C,你能做什么?对任何年轻人(即任何还没有取得科学界的永久职位的人)来说,s u ]
首要任务是去找一份其他的工作,这讲是你避免失望的痛苦。美国年轻的一代已经觉醒
,看到了科学界黯淡的发展前景以及无法拥有一个合理的中产阶级生活,因此他们已经
不愿意做科学家。如果你还没有觉醒的话,赶紧加入他们的行列。把博士班留给印度人
和中国人吧―― 他们的家乡情况更糟。在我所认识的人C o f中,人生被读物理博士所毁的
人数比被毒品所毁的人还0 2 K要多。
If you are in a position of leadership in s; Z Ncience then you should try to
persuadh m m ^ H Z }e the funding$ r ~ T \ O agencies to train fewer Ph.D.s. The glut of scientis, | : ! Rts
is entirely the consequence of funding policies (almost all graduate
education is paid for by federal grants). The funding agenci? ^ v e ;es aD ( . –re bemoaning
tm N w 4he scarcity of young people interested in science when they th+ . H k ! n E A Gemselve# r rs
caused this scarcity b{ ^ ( ^ M ( Yy destroying science as a career. They could reverse
this sit% ? Q $ Y $uation by matching the number trained to the demand,1 W _ but theP E u ly refuse
to do so, or even to discuss the problem ses @ y – 8 \riously (for many years the NSF
propagated a dishonest prediction of a coming shortage of scientists, and
most funding agencies still act as if this were true). The result is that
the best young people, who should go into science, s/ | { e D sensio k pbly refuse to do so,
and the graduate schools are filled with weak American students and with
foreigners lured by the American student visa.
如果你身居高位,能够领导科学界,那么你应该尝试着去劝说那些发放研究经费的部门
少招些博士生。大街上! $ W 7 {论吨撮的科学家完全就是他们的资助政策的后果――几乎所有的
博士生都是由联邦基金支持的)。那些基金会总在抱怨很: / ^ v少有年轻人对科学感兴趣,而
造成这种结果的原因t d .正W N 4 Y是他, F ]们毁了科学作为事业。他们本可以扭转这种局面,只要他们
少招些博士生,让博士5 M 0 G j X |生D 0 X 1 f 9的人数与教职的人数大致相当就可以了,但他们不干,甚至他
们根本不屑于严肃地讨论这件事(许多年来,NSF到处宣扬他们虚假的预测,说科学家
短缺,而多数基金会好像真以为是这么回事)。结果就是,最好的年轻人,本该去做科
学家的,对此唯恐避之不及;而博士班里是一帮弱弱的美国学生,还有一帮被美国学生
签证所吸引来的外国人。

© 版权声明
THE END
喜欢就支持一下吧
点赞0